The pBook vs eBook: Dial D For Dilemma…
“Our dilemma is that we hate change and love it at the same time; what we really want is for things to remain the same but get better.” Sydney J. Harris
Paperback — nothing beats opening up a brand new book or rummaging through a bookstore. 75.77% (294 votes)
ebooks — you can get new books in a flash and bring multiple reads with you everywhere you go. 24.23% (94 votes)
Total Votes: 388 ( Results of WP Daily Post Poll)
Writing Challenge: Do You Prefer pBooks or eBooks? The written word has had a long and varied history. Whether we look at the earliest scrolls from the 2nd Century AD or the oldest surviving book – the Derveni papyrus from 340 BC, or the modern day ebook first published in 1971, what stands out is that the written word is here to stay. The dilemma is in deciding if we prefer to read pBooks (physical copies) or eBooks (electronic copies). I grew up in a household filled with books. They were a lifeline in a sometimes challenging world, and I passed on the love of books to my kids. I love reading and I love books.
Naturally, the joy many of us derive from reading begins with the hard/soft copy; it speaks to the tactile sensation we get from holding a book, the thrill we feel leafing through the pages, marking where we stopped, smelling it, sharing our books, and/or creating a library of books we plan to donate or give away some day. I have an extensive library of books from around the world, and I still buy physical copies of new, used, and collectible books. But, I am not adverse to eBooks and have some in my collection too. When I checked the WP poll above, 75% of WP readers still preferred reading physical copies… However, I must add that a decent number of WP Bloggers left comments that they liked both and would have appreciated a third poll option which wasn’t provided. So where do you stand on this topic? pBook or ebook?
1971: Project Gutenberg is the first digital library
1990: The web boosts the internet
1993: The Online Books Page is a list of free ebooks
1994: Some publishers get bold and go digital
1995: Amazon.com is the first main online bookstore
1996: There are more and more texts online
1997: Multimedia convergence and employment
1998: Libraries take over the web
1999: Librarians get digital Ebook History by M. Lebert
Do you love the convenience of eBooks, or the texture of paper? When I read the Daily Post prompt, my first thought was “Why choose?” I like both; hence the dilemma. When we consider the history of the pBook and hold it up to the genesis and rapid growth of the eBook, something becomes apparent; the eBook has the potential to become a strong contender as the preferred choice of the future. Why?
For starters, aside from its tactile limitations, it offers a number of conveniences: eBooks save shelf space, we can download hundreds of books on an eReader and travel with ease, we can delete, replace and purchase new eBooks from the comfort of our home, and because there are no physical stores, the pricing is cheaper and time/cost of travel is eliminated. Finally, the ebook has given many people a quick way to become a published author. If you never imagined getting a traditional publishing house contract, the eBook will make your publishing dream come true pretty quickly. So what’s the beef? More below!
“There is no dilemma compared with that of the deep-sea diver who hears the message from the ship above, “Come up at once. We are sinking.”” Robert Cooper
2000: Information is available in many languages
2001: Copyright, copyleft and Creative Commons
2002: A web of knowledge
2003: eBooks are sold worldwide
2004: Authors are creative on the net
2005: Google gets interested in ebooks
2006: Towards a world public digital library
2007: We read on various electronic devices
2008: “A common information space in which we communicate Ebook History by M. Lebert
What’s the beef and what about the future? The challenge for many of us is that we grew up with a certain norm; physical copies of books. We prefer pBooks for the reasons stated at the beginning of this post, and, because many book lovers still cherish the feel and smell of a book, we automatically reach for a pBook. Humans are creatures of habit and it takes time to convert people to a new order or idea; especially when the idea has to do with our reading preferences.
Another important point to remember when we discuss pBooks is that we have universities and archives around the world with important historical records; books made of paper, clay and other materials, and they would not be exchanged for the cold touch of an eReader. That said, the eBook has created a window of opportunity that will continue to have an impact on the world of books… Dilemma or not, it’s here to stay. What are your thoughts? Stay Inspired. Have a blessed day and thank you for stopping by!
*Please bear with me as I continue to catch up on your blogs. Thank you all for your patience!
Happy 2013! This post was inspired by a prompt from WP Daily Post: Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind the Gap – How do you prefer to read, with an eReader like a Kindle or Nook, or with an old school paperback in hand? Take the poll and then explain your opinion by blogging about it on your site.
Positive Motivation Tip: A book, a kindle, a nook a day might keep the doctor and a wasted mind away. Give someone a book today!
- How eBooks Can Help Your Business (sarahwritesstories.com)
- Amazon: Attack Your Day Before It Attacks You eBook (Free Kindle Download) – $19.99 Value (hip2save.com)
- Infographic: Who Reads eBooks? (the-digital-reader.com)
- Weekly Writing Challenge: If Only « One Starving Activist
- Weekly Writing Challenge: Print vs. Digital Books « The Road to Personal Success
- DP Challenge: Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind the Gap (EBook or Hard Copy?) | My Blog
- Her essence « Master Of Disaster
- Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind the Gap | thelissachronicles
- Weekly Challenge: Mind The Gap, Ebooks or Paperback? « Casual, Possibly-Nonsensical Ramblings
- Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind the Gap | …and she writes
- How Acting Like A Kid Improves Mental Health « Broken Light: A Photography Collective
- My Book-less Semester: Week 1 | Writing My Next Chapter
- I’m a bookworm, are you? « Sue’ s considered trifles
- Paperback or E-Reader – the fight is on! « Talk About Cheesecake
- news title, hurray! « kissanjusha
- eBooks or Paperbacks – an anthropological answer* | bentrigg.co.uk
- Mind the Gap | Sammy’s Moleskin
- Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind the Gap | Diary of a Recovering Fiend
- Mind The Gap: The Clumsy Me Test | EL Appleby: Short Stories
- Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind the Gap « Lady Lovely Blogger
- Weekly Writing Challenge: Mind The Gap « A woman with an internal GPS
- I Am a Reader; I will Not Compromise | Shadoza: In My World